Rare ( in general )

Not Rare ( in general )

• Pre-1925 catalogs (any company)

• Heddon "The Why of It" paper

• Heddon Dummy Double paper

• Heddon two and three belly wt. lures

• Heddon "high forehead" lures

• Heddon two piece hardware

• Heddon Spindiver

• Heddon Black Sucker

• Pflueger gem clip hardware lures

• Shakespeare gem clip hardware lures

• Shakespeare wood boxes

• Heddon wood boxes

• Pflueger wood boxes

• Pflueger contract boxes

• Pflueger Four Bros. boxes

• Creek Chub "special order" lures

• Creek Chub 6 or 12 packs

• Heddon lures in Sienna

• Heddon lures in copper

• Heddon lures in gold

• Heddon lures in slate back

• Heddon lures in frog scale

• Heddon lures in blue scale

• Heddon lures in all yellow

• Heddon lures in brown natural scale

• Heddon lures in white strawberry spot

• Pflueger maroon boxes

• Pflueger Monarchs

• Pflueger Electric Minnows

• Shakespeare Punkinseeds

• Heddon white boxes

• Heddon Pine Tree box

• Heddon Picture boxes

• Shakespeare black boxes

• Shakespeare picture boxes

• Creek Chub five hook minnows

• Creek Chub intro boxes

• Rhodes lures and boxes

• South Bend underwater minnows

• South Bend Combination minnow

• Heddon 800, 900, 700

• Heddon Giant Vamp

• Creek Chub Bug Wiggler

• Creek Chub Wee Dee, Sucker

• Heddon "Woodpecker"

• Heddon "Dowagiac" underwater

• Heddon 5 hk. Slopenose

• Heddon Killer

• Heddon six hook 300

• Heddon Dummy Double

• Heddon Black Sucker

• Heddon Coast minnow

• Heddon Luny frog in red and white

• Muskys from major companies

• Heddon ice decoy

• "Experts" any... Woods, Clark, etc.

• Moonlight underwater minnow

• Pflueger Trory minnow

• Kent Floaters with carved eye

• Arbogast Spotted Ape Jitterbug

• Pflueger Monarch minnows

• Pflueger metalized minnows

• Pflueger baby Surprise minnow

• Shakespeare Musky lures

• Shakespeare Sure Lure

• Shakespeare Albany lure

• Shakespeare "high forehead" minnow

• Shakespeare Whirlwind

• Shakespeare 03

• Shakespeare Kazoo box

• Shakespeare Barnacle Bill

• Shakespeare Tarpalunge G.E.

• Worden Combination minnow

• Min-Buck minnow, SB

• South Bend Truck-Oreno

• Howe's Vacuum bait

• Glass minnow tubes

• Most early Misc. Minnows

• Anything pre-1920 NIB

• North Channel minnow

• Red Fin minnow

• Michigan Life-Like

• Lane's Automatic

• Joe Pepper lures

• Miller's Reversible

• Clinton Wilt baits

• Winchester's with exc. paint

• Most Introductory boxes

• Rhodes Mechanical frog or box

• Shakespeare Musky wood box

• Octopus minnow

• Jersey Expert

• Bing's Nemahbin minnow

• Charmers

• Rotary Marvel

• A "real" Helgramite

• Red Fin minnow by  Donaly Baits

• Holzwarth minnow

• K & K Animated minnow (exc. cond.)

• Chippewa Musky size

• Harkauf Wooden minnow

• Kellman bugs

• Pfeiffer glass minnow tubes

• Rhodes Perfect Casting Bait

• Welch and Graves glass tube

• Wilcox Wiggler

• Heddon advertizing and displays

• Salesman sample cases pre-1940

• Heddon Airplane (real one)

• Pardee Minnow

• Haskell Minnow (real one)

• Pepper minnows or any kind

• North Channel or Delavan minnow

• Nemo Revolving minnow

• Decker underwater minnow

• Eclipse minnow

• Smith minnow

• The Chautaugua minnow

• Pontiac minnows

• Ewert's artificial bait

IN GENERAL...:

• Most post 1940 lures

• Heddon post 1940 catalogs

• Fake Heddon handcarved frogs

• Heddon L-rig hardware

• Heddon "spook" anything

• Pflueger lures in Neverfail hardware

• Shakespeare Flat plate hardware

• Shakespeare orange and blue boxes

• Heddon lures in green crackle back

• Heddon lures in rainbow

• Heddon Punkinseeds in general

• Heddon plastic Punkinseeds

• Heddon up leaping Bass boxes

• Creek Chub tack eye baits

• Creek Chub in general after 1930

• Creek Chub in Pikie finish

• Heddon 200's or 210's

• Heddon Multiple minnows

• Heddon Tad Polly

• South Bend red and white anything

• South Bend rainbow

• Heddon Vamps

• Creek Chub Wiggler

• Creek Chub Ding Bat

• Heddon Artistic minnow

• Heddon fat bodies in 100 or 150

• Heddon Crab Wigglers

• Heddon Lucky 13

• Heddon Luny frog in frog

• Heddon anything in surface rig

• Heddon spook anything

• Heddon River Runt spooks

• Heddon SOS

• Heddon Torpedo

• Heddon Crazy Crawler

• Heddon Gamefisher

• Heddon mouse

• Heddon Feathertail

• Heddon Weedless Widow

• Paw Paw Wottafrog

• Paw Paw in general

• Kent floater with Neverfail hardware

• Pflueger Surprise minnow

• Pal-o-mines

• Rush Tango's in general

• Shakespeare Revolutions (late)

• Shakespeare Evolutions (late)

• Shakespeare Slim Jim (late)

• Shakespeare Waukazoo

• Shakespeare Jim Dandy lures

• Shakespeare Tarpalunge P.E.

• South Bend Whirl-Oreno

• South Bend Vacuum Bait

• South Bend Bass-Oreno

• Wilson Wobbler

• Decker top water revolving bait

• Flood minnows

• Most Florida baits

• Pflueger Phantoms

• Winchester Wobblers

• Tad Polly Intro box

• Shakespeare Floating Spinner

• Carter's Dunks lures

• Bite-em-Bate

• Water Scout

• Fake Helgramite

• Detroit Glass minnow

• Most rubber baits

• South Bend flyrod lures

• Du Getum's

• The "reel" lure

• Bud Stewart baits

• Shur-Strike lures

• L&S plastic lures

• Thoren Minnow Chaser

• Almost anything by Arbogast

• Devon minnows

• Most lures by Foss